Will all the “real men” please stand up?
Last Saturday I went to Chopsticks, a dueling piano bar in Everett, for a friend’s birthday. This is always a great time, where two pianists banter back and forth, singing almost every song the audience requests, joking, making fun of each other and providing a very entertaining show. They are high-energy and big on audience participation.
It is customary to bring people who are celebrating their birthday up on stage to jokingly humiliate them, and the victim this particular night was an adorable girl who was celebrating her 21st birthday. The lead pianist, Mr. Billy Mac, decided it would be clever to have all the men in the audience sing “You’ve Lost that Lovin’ Feelin” to the girl, ”just like in Top Gun.”
So what does Billy Mac do? He silences the audience, and asks for, “All the real men. All the real, straight heterosexual men in the audience to please stand up.” There was a strange hush in the audience, as everyone got the buzz that something wasn’t right about this question. I was so embarrassed for any gay men (out or not) in the audience, and I sank down so low in my seat you’d think he’d called me out by name. Unsurprisingly, many men who hadn’t participated much during the rest of the show suddenly shot out of their seats, just to be SURE there was no confusion about their sexuality, and they were all just standing there, looking so. . . smug and manly. . .and I was too ashamed to look and see if any men were still seated.
As I’m looking around the room at all these supposed real men, I can’t help but wonder how many of them go home and smack their kids around or cheat on their wives. In contrast, images of gay men gardening keep popping into my head. I realize the world is not black or white – not all straight men are assholes and not all gay men are loving and devoted. But I still can’t figure how being straight automatically makes you a real man.
Perhaps I’m giving Billy Mac too much credit, but what I believe he was trying to say (though failing miserably), was that he wanted all the men who are attracted to women to stand up. But what he did was help strengthen a long-standing stereotype that gay men aren’t real men.
I’m sorry, but choosing to put your penis into a vagina does not make you a man. Hell, even owning a penis doesn’t make you a man. . .does it?
Some will argue that unless you were born a man, you are not a man. I guess I can support that claim on a technicality, but frankly, I consider it mean and pointless. I know a couple of men (masculine, attracted to women) who were not born men, and it would seem downright silly to look at them and say, “you are not a man.” Or to tell the big teddy bear, leather daddies that they aren’t real men, because they’re attracted to other big, hairy lumberjack-type men (isn’t this how the mainstream defines masculinity?).
What do you think makes a man? Is it having a penis? Is it to act according to manliness, and who defines that? Whose standards are we measuring against? Is it how each person identifies? Is that realistic? Is it based on what gender you find attractive?
One person said “being a real man means taking care of your business (aka bills, children, being a responsible human being, etc.).” Based on that logic, I could be considered a man.
Another person said, “It’s what letter you have under ’sex’ on your driver’s license.” By that logic, transsexuals who live as women are more manly than gay men? Does this also mean that just because you can’t afford, or choose not to have the gender reassigment surgery that you don’t count?
While I believe Billy Mac at Chopsticks was just trying to be entertaining, I believe a lot of people had the potential of being hurt by his thoughtless remark, and he sure opened up Pandora’s Box for me.















